Does Rafa Know What He’s Doing?

18 06 2009
70 players in, 72 players out. That’s 142 transfer deals in 5 seasons, an average of
almost 30 players per season!
~
His total net spend was just on £82 million for an average of around £16 million
per season and still no silverware for 3 years on the trot!
~
If I was a Liverpool fan I will be asking a lot of questions like
“Should any quality manager make this multitude of mistakes in transfers?
“Does Rafa have any knowledge of the true £ value of the players he buys?”
“How many millions went directly into the pockets of player agents?”
“How many agents were involved in these deals? Were they the same
ones over and over again or where there a large number involved?”
Does it matter? Think about it.
~
Of course there is no suggestion that brown paper bags stuffed with cash has ever
changed hands. Am I simply being suspicious? Of course I am. Like everything
else in life, the older you get the more cynical you become.

This particular blog is not related to Manchester United, I’m fully aware of that but it could be of  interest especially when compared to Fergusons transfer deals in his first five seasons at Old Trafford as can be seen on this website

http://www.geocities.com/Colosseum/6003/transfer.html


Rafa traded 70 players in and 72 players out. That’s a huge 142 transfer deals in 5 seasons, an average of almost 30 players per season!


His total net spend was just on £82 million for an average of around £16 million per season and still no silverware for 3 years on the trot!


If I was a Liverpool fan I will be asking a lot of questions like


Should any quality manager make this multitude of mistakes in transfers?


“Does Rafa have any knowledge of the true £ value of the players he buys?”


“How many millions went directly into the pockets of player agents?”


“How many agents were involved in these deals? Were they the same ones over and over again or were there a large number involved?” Does it matter? Think about it.


Of course there is no suggestion that brown paper bags stuffed with cash has ever changed hands. Am I simply being suspicious? Of course I am. Like everything else in life, the older you get the more cynical you become.


Check out this piece from The Times and see what you think


The Benitez Years: His Transfers In Full

By James Ducker, The Times, 15 June 2009

Players signed: 70……Players sold or let go: 72

Total gross spend £191.309m…..Total recouped £109.51m

Total net spend £81.799m

2004

IN (4)

Xabi Alonso (Real Sociedad, £10.5m); Luis Garcia (Barcelona, £6m); Josemi (Malaga, £2m); Antonio Nunez (Real Madrid, free).


OUT (3)

Michael Owen (Real Madrid, £8m); Danny Murphy (Charlton Athletic, £2.5m); Markus Babbel (VfB Stuttgart, free).

Spent £18.5m…Recouped £10.5m…Net spend £8m

2005

IN (14)

Peter Crouch (Southampton, £7m); Fernando Morientes (Real Madrid, £6.3m); Jose Manuel Reina (Villarreal, £6m); Mohamed Sissoko (Valencia, £5.6m); Mark Gonzalez (Albacete, £3.5m); Scott Carson (Leeds United, £750,000); Antonio Barragan (Seville, £240,000); Besian Idrizaj (Linzer ASK, £190,000); Jack Hobbs (Lincoln City, £150,000); Mauricio Pellegrino (Valencia, free); Boudewijn Zenden (Middlesbrough, free); Godwin Antwi (Real Zaragoza, free); Ramon Calliste (Manchester United, free), Miki Roque (Llieda, free)


OUT (14)

Milan Baros (Aston Villa, £6.5m); El-Hadji Diouf (Bolton, £4.5m); Alou Diarra (Lens, £2m); Antonio Nunez (Celta Vigo, £2m); Igor Biscan (Panathinaikos, free); Stephane Henchoz (Celtic, free); Mauricio Pellegrino (Alaves, free); Vladimir Smicer (Bordeaux, free); Gregory Vignal (Portsmouth, free); Paul Harrison (Wolves, free); Jon Otsemobor (Rotherham United, free); Ritchie Partridge (Sheffield Wednesday, free); Mark Smyth (Accrington, free); Patrice Luzi (released).


Spent £29.73m; recouped £15m; net spend £14.73m


2006

IN (11)

Dirk Kuyt (Feyenoord, £9m); Jermaine Pennant (Birmingham City, £6.7m); Craig Bellamy (Blackburn Rovers, £6m); Daniel Agger (Brondby, £5.8m); Gabriel Paletta (Banfield, £2m); Fabio Aurelio (Valencia, free); Nabil El Zhar (St Etienne, free); Robbie Fowler (Manchester City, free); Jan Kromkamp (Villarreal, free); Paul Anderson (Hull City, free); David Martin (MK Dons, free)


OUT (19)

Chris Kirkland (Wigan Athletic, £3.5m); Fernando Morientes (Valencia, £3.1m); Jan Kromkamp (PSV Eindhoven, £2m); Djimi Traore (Charlton Athletic, £2m); Antonio Barragan (Deportivo La Coruna, £680,000); Neil Mellor (Preston North End, £500,000); Dietmar Hamann (Manchester City via Bolton Wanderers, £400,000); Bruno Cheyrou (Rennes, free); Josemi (Villarreal, free); Ramon Calliste (Scunthorpe United, free); Robbie Foy (Scunthorpe United, free); Carl Medjani (Leyton Orient, free); Conal Platt (Bournemouth, free); David Raven (Carlisle United, free); John Welsh (Hull City, free); Zak Whitbread (Millwall, free); Calum Woods (Dunfermline, free); Ryan Wilkie (released); Paul Willis (released).

Spent £29.5m; recouped £12.18m; net spend £17.32m


2007

IN (26)

Fernando Torres (Atletico Madrid, £20.2m); Javier Mascherano (West Ham United, £18.6m); Ryan Babel (Ajax, £11.5m); Lucas Leiva (Gremio, £6m); Yossi Benayoun (West Ham United, £5m); Alvaro Arbeloa (Deportivo La Coruna, £2.6m); S Leto (Lanus, £1.85m); Mikel San Jose (Athletic Bilbao, £270,000); Krisztian Nemeth (MTK, £100,000); Dani Pacheco (Barcelona, £100,000); Alexander Kacaniklic (Helsingborgs, £75,000); Andriy Voronin (Bayer Leverkusen, free); Emiliano Insua (Boca Juniors, free); Charles Itandje (Lens, free); Damien Plessis (Lyons, free); Mikail Alexandrov (CSKA Sofia, free); Jordy Brouwer (Ajax, free); Gerardo Bruna (Real Madrid, free); Ryan Crowther (Stockport County, free); Francisco Manuel Duran (Malaga, free); Ronald Huth (Tacuary FC, free); Gary Mackay Steven (Ross County, free); Nikolay Mihaylov (Levski Sofia, free); Marvin Pourie (Borussia Dortmund, free); Andras Simon (MTK Hungaria, free); Danielle Padelli (Sampdoria, loan)


OUT (18)

Craig Bellamy (West Ham United, £7.5m); Djibril Cisse (Marseille, £6m); Mark Gonzalez (Real Betis, £4.2m); Luis Garcia (Atletico Madrid, £4m); Florent Sinama-Pongolle (Recreativo Huelva, £2.7m); Stephen Warnock (Blackburn Rovers, £1.5m); Darren Potter (Wolverhampton Wanderers, £250,000); Daniel O’Donnell (Crewe Alexandra, £100,000); Salif Diao (Stoke City, free); Jerzy Dudek (Real Madrid, free); Robbie Fowler (Cardiff City, free); Gabriel Paletta (Boca Juniors, free); Boudewijn Zenden (Marseille, free); David Mannix (Ham-Kam, free); Jay Smith (Stockport County, free); Francisco Manuel Duran (released); Dave Roberts (released); Daniele Padelli (Sampdoria, end of loan)

Spent £66.295m; recouped £26.25; net spend £40.045m


2008

IN (14)

Robbie Keane (Tottenham Hotspur, £20.3m); Albert Riera (Espanyol, £8m); Andrea Dossena (Udinese, £7m); Martin Skrtel (Zenit St Petersburg, £6.5m); Diego Cavalieri (Palmeiras, £3.5m); David Ngog (Paris St Germain, £1.5m); Alex Cooper (Ross County, £100,000); Philipp Degen (Borussia Dortmund, free); Lauri Dalla Valle (Jippo, free); Vitor Flora (Botafogo, free); Peter Gulacsi (MTK Hungaria, free); Emmanuel Mendy (Murcia Deportivo, free); Nikola Saric (Herfolge, free); Vincent Lucas Weijl (AZ Alkmaar, free)


OUT (15)

Peter Crouch (Portsmouth, £11m); Mohammed Sissoko (Juventus, £8.2m); John Arne Riise (AS Roma, £3.98m); Scott Carson (West Bromwich Albion, £3.75m); Danny Guthrie (Newcastle United, £2.5m); Steve Finnan (Espanyol, free); Harry Kewell (Galatasaray, free); Anthony Le Tallec (Le Mans, free); Besian Idrazaj (Wacker Tirol, free); Lee Peltier (Yeovil Town, free); San Jose Dominguez (released); Craig Lindfield (released); Ray Putterill (released); Miki Roque (released); James Smith (released).

Spent £46.9m; recouped £29.43m; net spend £17.47m


2009

IN (1)

Victor Palsson (Aarhus GF, £384,000)


OUT (3)

Robbie Keane (Tottenham Hotspur, £16m); Sami Hyypia (Bayer Leverkusen, free), J Hobbs (Leicester City, £150,000).

Spent £0.384m; recouped £16m; net spend (-£15.766m)


So there you have it, compared to Rafas 70 in and 72 out (142 Deals) during his first 5 years, Ferguson brought in 21 and sold 29 (50 Deals)


Fergusons deals worked out to a nett outlay of just under 19 million pounds while Rafa’s nett was nearly 82 million.


Comparing the amount spent between the two is not realistic because of the high inflation of transfer fees but a difference of 63million is a hell of an amount as is 142 to 50 player deals.

Share Share

Advertisements

Actions

Information

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




%d bloggers like this: